 |
In English, it
is very common to use one noun to describe another noun, for example
heart disease (a two-noun cluster). This phrase has the same
meaning as cardiac disease (an adjective and a noun), and
the two phrases can be used interchangeably. Two-noun clusters are
acceptable and usually cause no problem for the reader. However,
if three or more nouns are used in one cluster, to the point where
there is a long string of nouns and adjectives modifying one another,
problems arise. First of all, the reader easily gets lost before
he reaches the main noun. Note the following example of poor writing
that was actually published. |
| |
 |
Five two week old single comb white leghorn
specific pathogen free chickens were inoculated with approximately
105 tissue culture infected doses of duck adenovirus. |
|
| |
If you cannot understand this,
don't feel bad because I can't either. The noun 'chickens' has
11 words describing it! The sentence is very difficult to understand
because the reader is
unsure which
nouns
are substantive
and which are modifiers. |
|
Many scientific writers make this
error because they are trying very hard to be brief. In my first
set of tips, I instructed that brevity should be a goal
in scientific writing. However, clarity is always more important
than brevity. The following example is obviously brief, however
it is not clear and could be interpreted in many different ways.
Even though it is not necessarily from a scientific report, similar
occurrences can be found in literature from every academic field. |
| |
aged
dog meat samples |
| |
| This phrase could have at least five
different meanings: |
| |
- samples of aged meat fed to
dogs
- samples of aged meat from the bodies
of dogs
- aged samples of meat from the bodies
of dogs
- aged samples of meat fed to dogs
- samples of meat from the bodies of
aged dogs
|
| |
When you edit your own article (which
you should do BEFORE you send it to E-World Editing or any native-speaking
editor), try to circle every group of more than two nouns.Your goal
is to reduce these strings to simple pairs. There is a saying in
English that is useful to remember; "Two is company, three is a
crowd." While this phrase usually refers to a couple who wants to
be alone, it also applies to this method. The following are some
examples of phrases that contain a string of nouns or adjectives,
and beside them are clearer revisions. |
| |
|
|
|
| A system necessitated automated motor
starting circuit |
|
An automated motor-starting circuit required
by the system |
| A 4 month secretory cell produced mucosal
accumulation history |
|
A 4-month history of accumulation of
mucosa produced by secretory cells |
| The negative penicillin skin test result
group |
|
The group with negative results on the
penicillin skin test |
| Blue absorbing pigment spectral curve |
|
Spectral curve for blue-absorbing pigment |
| Climate controlled gene cluster phenotype
variation |
|
Climatically controlled variation in
gene-cluster phenotype |
| Two dimensional real time ultrasonographic
blood flow detection techniques |
|
Ultrasonography techniques that detect
blood flow in two-dimensional real time |
| A calibrated transit time ultrasonic
blood flow probe cable end |
|
The cable end from an ultrasonic blood-flow
probe calibrated to measure transit time ultrasonically |
|
| |
Before you begin to take apart these long strings
in your own paper, be sure to determine the precise relationship
of one word to another. Then express this relationship by adding
the necessary prepositions, commas, and hyphens. Be careful that
you do not unintentionally change the meaning.
|
| |
| The following are some exercises you can do to practice.
When you are finished, feel free to email your answers to me at jerry@eworldediting.com for comments
and help. Good luck! |
| |
| |
| EXERCISES: |
| |
| A. Remove the ambiguity from the
strings of nouns and adjectives listed below. You can rewrite each
more than once to express different meanings. |
| |
- mature muscle iron
- chronic depression symptoms
- renal lithium excretion
|
| |
| B. Improve the sentences below. In order to do so, you may need to choose a meaning because of the
ambiguous phrases. Therefore, more than one answer is possible and your revision should be judged by its
clarity. |
| |
- The three cases all had histologically confirmed metastatic
malignant intra-abdominal tumors.
- The present study examines various immunospecific drug sample combinations and their inhibition producing effects upon human
peripheral blood leukocytes.
|
| |
|
|